| When Sarah Palin said Kelly Ayotte fought Planned Parenthood "all the way to the Supreme Court and won," she got it wrong. Wrong, as in the truth is Kelly Ayotte fought Planned Parenthood all the way to the Supreme Court and lost.
That's not my opinion. That's the legal opinion of the presiding judge who ruled New Hampshire had to reimburse Planned Parenthood for legal costs.
Nashua Telegraph (8/16/2008):
The state of New Hampshire must reimburse Planned Parenthood of New England for a lawsuit, in which the group challenged the state's 2003 parental notification law, a federal judge has ruled.
In his ruling last week, DeClerico said PPNNE effectively won the suit and deserved to be reimbursed a "reasonable award of legal fees and costs."
Now, Sarah Palin has never let the facts get in the way of a good story, but it still seems unlikely that she would have intentionally reversed the outcome when the truth can be confirmed so easily.
So this leads to some interesting questions for Kelly Ayotte. Do you believe you "won" the Supreme Court case? Did you or your staff discuss the case with Palin before the endorsement? Have you notified Palin of the inaccuracy in her statement?
Cross-posted to Miscellany Blue |