About
Learn More about our progressive online community for the Granite State.

Create an account today (it's free and easy) and get started!
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Search




Advanced Search


The Masthead
Managing Editor
Mike Hoefer

Editors
elwood
susanthe
William Tucker
The Roll, Etc.
Prog Blogs, Orgs & Alumni
Bank Slate
Betsy Devine
birch paper
Democracy for NH
Granite State Progress
Mike Caulfield
Miscellany Blue
Pickup Patriots
Re-BlueNH
Susan the Bruce
New Hampshire Labor News
Chaz Proulx: Right Wing Watch
Defending New Hampshire Public Education

Politicos & Punditry
The Burt Cohen Show
John Gregg
Landrigan
Pindell
Primary Monitor
Scala
Schoenberg
Spiliotes
NewsViewsBlues- Arnesen

Campaigns, Et Alia.
NH-Gov
- Jackie Cilley
- Maggie Hassan
NH-01
- Carol Shea-Porter
- Matthew Hancock
NH-02
- Ann McLane Kuster
NH-Senate
- D4: David Waters
- D9: Lee Nyquist
NH-Executive Council
- D2: Colin Van Ostern
- D4: Chris Pappas
- D5: Debora Pignatelli

ActBlue Hampshire
NHDP
DCCC
DSCC
DNC

National
Balloon Juice
billmon
Congress Matters
DailyKos
Digby
Eschaton
FiveThirtyEight
Hold Fast
Institute For Policy Studies
MyDD
Open Left
Senate Guru
Swing State Project
Talking Points Memo

50 State Blog Network
Alabama
Arizona
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Missouri
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Rhode Island
Tennessee
Texas
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin

Marjorie Porter's House Floor Unanimous Consent

by: Lucy Weber

Wed Feb 01, 2012 at 19:42:00 PM EST


(Well worth clicking below the fold... - promoted by elwood)

At the end of the day, by long House tradition, Unanimous Consent  is given to individual House members to talk about, well, pretty much anything.  Today, we had one member give a remembrance of a former member of the House who passed away recently.  Another member detailed some Civil War history.  In between, there was this remarkable speech, given by BlueHampshire's own Marjorie Porter, and posted here with her permission.  It was one of the best crafted and most effective speeches I have heard, ever.  

It is also a chilling rendition of how some of the current House members relate to our citizens.  Here is the text of the speech:

Lucy Weber :: Marjorie Porter's House Floor Unanimous Consent

Thank you Mr. Speaker.

Honorable Colleagues, I rise to tell you about a constituent of mine, who just celebrated his 90th birthday last weekend.

Phil Harvey was born and raised in Hillsboro.  His family has lived in town for generations, so his ties to the town and state are long and strong.  

After graduating valedictorian from Hillsboro high school, he left for college at Keene Teacher's College and Tufts University, and then on to the military and the wars.  

During WWII, Phil served his country honorably for four years as an Army Air Corps aerial navigator.  During the Korean War, he continued to serve, this time as an Operations and Training officer. Indeed, he has been a member of the Army Air Corps and the US Air Force continuously since 1942 for a total of 70 years.  He currently holds the rank of Lt. Col.

Phil Harvey is, in my opinion, a true patriot, one of the Greatest Generation.

After the wars, Phil continued his education, earning both a masters degree and a PhD from the University of Connecticut.  He went on to a successful career in the field of education and educational testing at ETS in New Jersey and Illinois.  He married and raised a family.

Phil retired to his hometown a few years ago.  Using his own funds, he purchased and renovated several old houses in his historic neighborhood to their former glory.  He spared no expense, and the results are simply stunning.  Single-handedly, he brought pride back to his neighborhood and to a struggling town.

But that is not all.  Phil has become the unofficial town historian, and is an active member of the town Historical Society.   He is active in his church affairs, serving on the board of trustees of the Smith Memorial Church.  He serves as a member of the Economic Development Commission for the town of Hillsboro, and is on the Kemp Park Development Committee and the Contoocook North Branch Local Advisory Committee.

And in 2008, at the age of 86, Phil ran for, and was elected to, this venerable House.  He served one term honorably, and then retired, saying he was getting "too old."  But I don't think of him as old.  He is still going strong.  He's one of the most knowledgeable, intelligent and giving men I have had the pleasure to know.  

Phil Harvey has served his country, his state, and his community all his life.

He is a true gentleman.  He is someone to respect and emulate.

He is retired from this house, but he still follows what is happening here in Concord.  This week, he exercised his right as a NH citizen to voice his opinion to us all by sending an email asking us to vote No on 5 bills before us today.

He received several replies which upset him, and he shared them with me.  Although it will be extremely difficult, I wish to read from one of them now.  

"...you are against the protection of individual liberties from the government... you are in favor of tyranny...you are in favor of a judge deciding who will live or die when they are sick... you are not proud of the long tradition of craftsmanship in New Hampshire...and you are a racist ...sorry you are in New Hampshire."  
The message continues with a quote from Sam Adams:
"If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen."  

Mr. Speaker, Members of this House, we like to refer to each other as "the honorable" in this, the People's House.  But this is a title we must earn.  I ask you, is this response to my constituent, a former member of this house, and your former colleague, honorable?

Mr. Speaker, Members of this House, we hear a lot about freedom, liberty, and the rights of citizens in this chamber.  I say every NH citizen has the right to be treated with dignity and respect in their dealings with the members of this house-even if we do not agree with their point of view.  

I say it is an honor and a privilege to serve the people of NH as a member of this house.  I say this type of response embarrasses all of us who hold this hallowed office.  It embarrasses and insults our citizens, and it embarrasses our great state.

Please, can't we all treat each other with respect?

Brava, Marjorie.  At the end, she received a standing ovation from ALL House members present.  I hope it carries over into the days to come.

Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

I agreed with Rep. Porter (1.00 / 1)
Not knowing the exact context (and wishing I did, to be clear) of the quotes provided, I still felt that the decorum due to the public and to each other was lacking and deserved to called out.  So did most of the members of the House, who agreed to record this speech in the Journal permanently.

Of course, I expect an equal defense when I see individuals using slurs against folks 'on my side of the aisle.'  

I wrote a long response to an email which I posted publicly last night (and shared with all Reps) and got very good feedback on from many on both sides.  In it, I commented, among other things, that I agreed with Gov. Lynch's comments about finding common ground and respect.  Not sure it's appropriate to post here, so I won't right now, unless asked.

BH's token Republican / Libertarian / TeaPartier / Free Stater, courtesy of a Federal Affirmative Action grant.


The context is right there. (4.00 / 11)
The gentleman, a veteran of World War II and Korea and a former House member himself, wrote to current members of the House. As thanks for expressing his views, he got a vicious attack on his patriotism.

It speaks volumes that you need more context.


[ Parent ]
the irony (1.00 / 4)
I have no interest in a heated exchange with you about this, elwood.  To do so is the very point of the entire issue.

Wanting to know more context is a perfectly valid response, but you want to find ways to deride that.  In doing so, you're part of the problem, not part of the solution.

BH's token Republican / Libertarian / TeaPartier / Free Stater, courtesy of a Federal Affirmative Action grant.


[ Parent ]
thanks for bringing this up, Seth (4.00 / 4)
You calling elwood "part of the problem" reminded me of a very real problem we face in NH.

From Free State Project founder Jason Soren's original manifesto of the intentions of the FSP:

Once we've taken over the state government, we can slash state and local budgets, which make up a sizeable proportion of the tax and regulatory burden we face every day. Furthermore, we can eliminate substantial federal interference by refusing to take highway funds and the strings attached to them. Once we've accomplished these things, we can bargain with the national government over reducing the role of the national government in our state. We can use the threat of secession as leverage to do this.



[ Parent ]
I got the same response.... (0.00 / 0)
So you are against the protection of individual liberties from the government - ok, just as long as you know this position on HB 1580, 1486 makes it clear you are in favor of tyranny; you position on 1147 shows you are in favor of a judge deciding who will live or die when they are sick; that you are not proud of the long tradition of craftsmanship in New Hampshire illustrated by 1430 and you are a racist by your lack of support for HCR2.  Glad to know it, sorry you are in New Hampshire.  AS Sam Adams once said: "If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen."    

"Just because you do not take an interest in politics, doesn't mean politics won't take an interest in you" - Pericles, 430 BCE

[ Parent ]
it's always (0.00 / 0)
about you, isn't it, Seth?


[ Parent ]
irony #2 (n/t) (0.00 / 0)


BH's token Republican / Libertarian / TeaPartier / Free Stater, courtesy of a Federal Affirmative Action grant.

[ Parent ]
I sent you the context (0.00 / 0)
in an email.  Did you get it?

You have not converted a man because you have silenced him.  (John Morley, 1838-1923)

[ Parent ]
I did, and I asked around... (4.00 / 2)
Without naming names, I'll say that I often disagree with the member who wrote that, and his response was uncalled for given the fairly bland email that sparked it. (I got the same email, as did all other members.)

Thank you for forwarding that to me, Rep. Porter, and again, I agree with your sentiments as expressed in the unanimous consent.

BH's token Republican / Libertarian / TeaPartier / Free Stater, courtesy of a Federal Affirmative Action grant.


[ Parent ]
You are welcome. (4.00 / 2)
I wish I could say that this was the first time a constituent came to me disturbed by a response received, but it was not.  And these responses were not all from the same person--there are others who have used insulting language and personal attacks when replying.  I just want it to stop.  

As a state rep in the minority, I've learned to let these attacks roll off my back when they are aimed at me or my party.  I figure it is part of the job I volunteered for, and as a good (Republican) friend in town told me when I was running, politics are dirty.

But the public should not have to wear armor when contacting their representatives.

Nuff said.

You have not converted a man because you have silenced him.  (John Morley, 1838-1923)


[ Parent ]
The level of incivility (4.00 / 4)
of the present House was not there when I served in 2007-2008. It just wasn't. The Democratic majority did not run things or allow things like that.

Also, that was the biennium O'Brien had been voted out.


[ Parent ]
a thread on Baldasaro's Facebook... (4.00 / 1)
Those of you who have access to Al Baldasaro's Facebook wall may be interested in a shockingly mean-spirited thread about Rep. Emerson & Copeland.


sitting state rep: running for re-election in 2012.


[ Parent ]
given some of what I've seen you say, Rep. Horrigan (1.00 / 4)
There are a number of shockingly mean spirited threads here at BH.  It happens, on both sides.  And it would nice if it all stopped but I won't hold my breath.

BH's token Republican / Libertarian / TeaPartier / Free Stater, courtesy of a Federal Affirmative Action grant.

[ Parent ]
tell us, Rep. Cohn (4.00 / 2)
do you whimper to Baldasaro and other fellow Republicans about the shockingly mean spirited things they say?

I thought not. You're just another GOP hypocrite, coming here to point fingers you'd never dream of pointing at your craven comrades.  


[ Parent ]
Inquiry (0.00 / 0)
Am I to understand that this and the other email came from other current members of the House. I read this several times and the verbiage is not clear on this point.  

Wearing a ring doesn't make you a bath tub.

The excerpts (4.00 / 5)
Are from an email sent this week by a current House member to Marjorie's constituent.

Here is a fact that should help you to fight a little longer.
Things that don't actually kill you outright make you stronger.

Piet Hein, Grooks


[ Parent ]
Thank you for the clarification. (4.00 / 1)


Wearing a ring doesn't make you a bath tub.

[ Parent ]
I have seen the full email. (0.00 / 0)
Stunning, disappointing, shameful...

Have you told a stranger today about Bill O'Brien and his Tea Party agenda? The people of NH deserve to hear about O'Brien  and his majority committed to destroying New Hampshire and remaking it into a armed survivalist preserve.  

[ Parent ]
All words that sum up the Republican leadership under Bill O'Brien. (4.00 / 2)
though I would change "disappointing" to "disrespectful".

"We start working to beat these guys right now." -Jed Bartlet

[ Parent ]
I received the same response (0.00 / 0)
It came from from Rep. Jordan Ulery of Hudson. I'm perplexed why people are protecting his identity?

[ Parent ]
we liberals forget (4.00 / 5)
We liberals forget that we are made of sturdier stuff than conservatives.  When we are not around conservatives, we argue with each other quite vociferously and even hurl some pretty choice insults at each other--- and at the end of the day we laugh it all off in a spirit of good fun.

We forget that our friends on the right aren't used to playing that game.  We forget how easily their feelings can be hurt.  Call a rightwinger a "teabagger" and he will drop his yellow rattlesnake flag on the ground and start crying like an overstimulated 3-year-old because his feelings have been hurt so bad.  That's just the way those people are: it's not necessarily because they are inherently stupid or weak (though many of them are stupid and weak), it's just because they haven't learned how to control their emotions, and they don't know how to deal with being criticized.

I served with Phil Harvey last term, and I know him to be a good man with a big heart and a peppery personality who always speaks his mind.  Sometimes what he had to say on the floor of the House was quite critical, and that went double for what he said in caucus. I can see why freshman Republicans would have a hard time dealing with his candor and his outspokenness.



sitting state rep: running for re-election in 2012.


something which hurt MY feelings (4.00 / 3)
Having just boasted about how tough we liberals are, I will now turn around and mention something which hurt my own feelings pretty badly.  A few minutes after Rep. Porter's speech, DJ Bettencourt hurled a a grossly homophobic tweet at Dean Barker:

@deanbarker Looking for a handbag, Dean?

Dean provoked DJ simply by retweeting a comment by NHPR's Josh Rogers:

Bettencourt to #nhhouse on spending temptations: "For men, a big-screen tv to watch the game on. For women, designer shoes and handbags."



sitting state rep: running for re-election in 2012.


Why have his parents not revoked internet privileges at home? n/t (4.00 / 3)


[ Parent ]
I thought (4.00 / 1)
he lived with his girlfriend out of his district.  I suppose we could ask her to revoke his internet privileges?

[ Parent ]
He claims they moved in with his parents in Salem. (0.00 / 0)


Have you told a stranger today about Bill O'Brien and his Tea Party agenda? The people of NH deserve to hear about O'Brien  and his majority committed to destroying New Hampshire and remaking it into a armed survivalist preserve.  

[ Parent ]
The DeeJay... (4.00 / 1)
Now lists an apartment complex next to Wal-Mart in North Salem as his address on the GC website.

http://www.gencourt.state.nh.u...

The funny part is, his Mommy swore up and down in comment sections on the UL that her darling "little" boy lived with her the entire time. The DeeJay had been caught living out of district you may recall. He shortly thereafter listed the new address in North Salem. I'm  sure its just a coincidence.  


[ Parent ]
according to the web site... (4.00 / 1)
The complex has a web site: units run from roughly $1200-$1600/month.  There are lots of places which cost more, and judging by the pictures the apartments are neither extravagant nor huge--- but that's not real cheap, either. He's certainly not paying for his rent out of his legislative salary.


sitting state rep: running for re-election in 2012.


[ Parent ]
when you worship at the altar of the GUN (3.50 / 2)
then all the venom, disgust, attacks, and over the top indignities are to be expected. Until weapons of death are put back into perspective, the self righteous will wrap themselves in patriotism, liberty and freedom and the rest of us will be treated not as the loyal opposition but nothing more than an apostate. There is no common ground, there is no bridge to build, there is only - Me right! You wrong!

It used to be said that man is a tool-using animal. That was wrong in the sense (0.00 / 0)
that it was supposed to make him unique. We now know, after having paid closer attention, that other creatures also use tools with intent and not just by happenstance as a collection of twigs makes a nest.
Moreover, additional close attention suggests that not all men are able to use tools, even though their hands have the requisite fingers and opposable thumbs.  Perhaps it's because they lack the necessary hand/eye coordination.  But, whatever the reason, some men are practically incompetent or, as we might say, "all thumbs." At most, they seem able to carry tools around and wave them randomly upon occasion to make an impression. And that, I would suggest, is what much of the gun culture is about--a sop for the practically incompetent.  
We should probably be grateful when men, who can't make things, only threaten, instead of actually destroying out of frustration.

[ Parent ]
An agenda of destruction (4.00 / 2)
Personal, political, social destruction -- all about destruction.  Every battle is between life and death. The gun is the symbolic mascot for this runaway id.

 "The future is not something to be predicted, it's something to be achieved,"  unattributed aphorism




correction (0.00 / 0)
"this runaway id death wish"

 "The future is not something to be predicted, it's something to be achieved,"  unattributed aphorism




[ Parent ]
Proud of the Honorable Marjorie Porter! (4.00 / 8)

Marjorie and I are in the second year of our freshman term in the Legislature.  Together, we have talked, commiserated, gone to lunch and learned the ropes on the huge learning curve required for this job.  Never have I been prouder of anyone in Concord than I was of Rep Porter yesterday.  What she did was hard, and in the great tradition of JFK's "Profiles in Courage."  In my book she represents the best of what having a citizen legislature should mean.  We need to find more just like her who put their moral convictions front and center.  You go girl!!!

"It is true that the law can't change the heart, but it can restrain the heartless."  Martin Luther King


Thank you. (4.00 / 3)


You have not converted a man because you have silenced him.  (John Morley, 1838-1923)

[ Parent ]
Thank you, Marjorie (4.00 / 3)
For forcing these people to confront their own moral bankruptcy!

 "The future is not something to be predicted, it's something to be achieved,"  unattributed aphorism




Thank you, Marjorie, (0.00 / 0)
for keeping it simple and concrete.  

Marjorie THANK YOU (0.00 / 0)
And thank to Lucy for bringing this to our attention.


May 19th@ New England College!

Connect with BH
     
Powered by: SoapBlox