About
Learn More about our progressive online community for the Granite State.

Create an account today (it's free and easy) and get started!
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Search




Advanced Search


The Masthead
Managing Editors
Dean Barker
Laura Clawson
Jennifer Daler

Contributing Writers
elwood
Mike Hoefer
susanthe
William Tucker

ActBlue Hampshire

The Roll, Etc.
Prog Blogs, Orgs & Alumni
Bank Slate
Betsy Devine
birch, finch, beech
Blue News Tribune (MA)
Democracy for NH
Live Free or Die
Mike Caulfield
Miscellany Blue
Granite State Progress
Seacoast for Change
Susan the Bruce
Tomorrow's Progressives

Politicos & Punditry
The Burt Cohen Show
John Gregg
Krauss
Landrigan
Lawson
Pindell
Primary Monitor
Primary Wire
Scala
Schoenberg
Spiliotes
Welch

Campaigns, Et Alia.
Paul Hodes
Carol Shea-Porter
Ann McLane Kuster
Katrina Swett
Jennifer Daler

ActBlue Hampshire
NHDP
DCCC
DSCC
DNC

National
Balloon Juice
billmon
Congress Matters
DailyKos
Digby
Hold Fast
Eschaton
FiveThirtyEight
MyDD
The Next Hurrah
Open Left
Senate Guru
Swing State Project
Talking Points Memo

50 State Blog Network
Alabama
Arizona
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Missouri
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin

Policy Straw Poll: Labor

by: Mike Caulfield

Wed Aug 08, 2007 at 21:27:01 PM EDT


OK, y'all know the rules. Two hundred words or less, contains a policy point in the first sentence and begins with the phrase "I am the only candidate who..."

Being at YearlyKos, I didn't do near my usual promotion/incessant nagging so we're short a couple of answers, but we'll let the couple we missed trickle in.

On the plus side, we're starting to see candidates really accentuate quntifiable differences here. Was the AFL-CIO debate only the beginning? I hope so -- I love a good policy brawl.

So without further ado, on the subject "Labor":

From Biden:

I am the only candidate to vote for the minimum wage increase that was enacted this year as part of the Supplemental bill that every other candidate voted against or said they would have. It was a unique opportunity to push through the minimum wage for our everyday heroes here at home. While Republicans usually block efforts to increase the minimum wage, we had them caught this time. I voted to provide our troops with the equipment they needed while providing working Americans with a long-overdue pay raise.

This administration declared war on labor the day they came in. I will put a stop to that. As president, the first thing I would do is appoint people to the NLRB who can say the word "Union." I am also a co-sponsor of EFCA, because if you get register to vote by signing your name, you ought to be able to register to join a union by signing your name.

I strongly opposed efforts to restrict OSHA coverage, I support the Family and Medical Leave Act and co-sponsor the Healthy Family Act, I opposed CAFTA and I will fight for better labor and environmental standards in trade agreements.

From Edwards:

I am the only candidate who has participated in over 200 activities during the last three years to support workers across the country.  I have helped more than 20 national unions organize thousands of workers.  Walking picket lines, calling and writing to employers, and meeting with workers, I have seen what unions go through to protect the right to organize, bargain collectively and get decent wages and health care for workers. We need a president who fights for working families, not corporate lobbyists and their clients.  We can?t trade our insiders for their insiders. 

Guaranteeing universal health care is the most important thing we can do to strengthen the middle class and working class in this country.  I was proud to be the first candidate to offer a detailed plan for true universal care that offers the option of a public plan for every American. As president, I will make passing the Employee Free Choice Act a top priority to give workers a real choice in whether to form a union. I will also ban the permanent replacement of striking workers, enact smart trade policies, protect prevailing wages and overtime pay, and issue mandatory rules for worker safety and real standards for outsourcing.

From Obama:

I am the only candidate whose policies have been shaped by firsthand experience working with communities in Chicago devastated by plant closings and the loss of industrial jobs. After the most anti-labor presidency in memory, all Democrats are committed to change. But it hasn't been a lack of good policies that have stopped us from achieving universal health care or a living wage or a secure retirement. It's a political system that gives too much influence to lobbyists and too little to the American people. I've walked the walk on these issues.  I recently walked the picket line with members of UNITE HERE Local 1 in Chicago, and I've said that if they are still fighting four years from now, I will be back on that picket line as President. I will also work to pass the Employee Free Choice Act because if a majority of workers in an organization want a union, they should get one. I'll also fight to expand collective bargaining rights, protect overtime pay, improve worker safety and prevent workplace discrimination.  And we'll create jobs in manufacturing and high-tech industries, and invest in transitional job programs. Finally, I will sign trade agreements that protect American workers and stand firm against agreements like CAFTA that fail to live up to our labor and environmental benchmarks.


From Dodd:

I am the only candidate who scored 100% on the 2006 AFL-CIO Congressional report card, and I've stood with unions for 32 years.  I fought through 7 years and 2 vetoes to pass the Family and Medical Leave Act, which allowed 50 million American workers to care for themselves or a family member without worrying about losing their jobs -- and I recently authored legislation expanding FMLA to include paid leave. I wrote the first federal childcare law since World War II, ensuring children have safe places to stay while their parents are working. I authored the FIRE and SAFER Acts, which provide firefighters the necessary equipment, training, and resources to do their jobs safely. And I wrote the RESPECT Act to overturn the Kentucky Rivers Decision that stripped collective bargaining rights from thousands of nurses and others.         

A vibrant labor movement will be a centerpiece of my Presidency because strong unions mean a stronger middle class and a stronger America. Union families know that I've had their backs for 32 years -- we've fought together to protect pensionsstrengthen our schools and expand access to affordable health care.  They've never had to look over their shoulder - and when I'm elected President, they never will.

From Hillary:

Hillary Clinton supports strong environmental and labor standards in trade agreements so that American workers can compete on a level playing field. She has introduced legislation to assess trade agreements every five years to make sure that they are being properly enforced.

Hillary is focused on keeping good jobs in America. She will take a hard look at the tax code to ensure that it is not rewarding companies for moving jobs overseas rather than creating jobs here.  She also believes it is important to invest in America's manufacturing capabilities.

Hillary is an original co-sponsor of the Employee Free Choice Act, which will level the playing field between workers and employers and ensure that employees will not be unfairly punished by their employers for attempting to unionize. 

Hillary has proposed a Strategic Energy Fund, which would provide $50b to stimulate job growth in all alternative energy fields in order to create jobs all across America.

Hillary will continue to fight for increases in the minimum wage and to peg Congressional pay raises to increases in the minimum wage.  Last night Hillary participated in the AFL-CIO Forum (see http://hillaryhub.co...), and she showed once again that, as President, she will be a champion for America's working men and women.

From Kucinich:

I am the only candidate who can answer this question without being forced to answer a follow up question for you to know my position on issues that affect the working people in America. "In my first week in office, I will notify Mexico and Canada that the United States is withdrawing from NAFTA. I will notify the WTO, that the United States is withdrawing from the WTO." Labor has stood almost alone while corporations have cut wages and benefits and jettisoned retirements through bankruptcy strategies. When the average CEO makes 531 times the average worker's pay we need changes in proportion to that discrepancy; anything less is a slap to our workers face. We have high unemployment and a decrepit infrastructure, millions of manufacturing and high-tech jobs are being shipped overseas. I have a plan that will turn our problems around. Pull out of NAFTA, return jobs that have been lost, including high-wage jobs in the information technology field. Initiate a WPA-style local jobs program that puts Americans back to work rebuilding America, we can create millions of jobs and simultaneously improve our quality of life. The Kucinich plan calls for the creation of a low-cost federal financing mechanism to administer $50 billion in zero-interest loans every year to localities for infrastructure projects for ten years. Twenty percent of these funds would be targeted for school construction and repair. The Kucinich plan also calls for a 15% reduction in the military budget, redirecting that $65 billion towards hometown security issues such as education, jobs, and health care for all.

From Richardson:

I am the only candidate for president who has advocated giving organized labor a real seat at the table: when I'm President, I will appoint a union member as my Secretary of Labor.  In recent years, unions across this country have raised their voices, but President Bush hasn't been listening.  In New Mexico, workers have never had to shout, because I've offered them a seat at the table.  That means we have union representatives on every state board affecting union membership, and in my cabinet.  One of my first acts as Governor was to restore collective bargaining rights to our hardworking state employees.  Now all public employees have the right to negotiate fair contracts, including fair share. My administration negotiated the first Public Works Project Labor Agreement in New Mexico history and we made our prevailing wage a union wage.  We dramatically increased health benefits for our state employees so now virtually every employee has access to quality affordable health insurance.  I've enjoyed the endorsements of every major union in my state.  As President, I will continue my record of fighting for workers, fighting for families and fighting for unions.
Mike Caulfield :: Policy Straw Poll: Labor
I'll be sending out a list of the subjects for the next 6 weeks soon, which should ease some of the overhead of arranging this.

Kucinich, Gravel, and Richardson -- we'll put it up as it comes in -- I know I skipped the normal backchannel emails this time

Poll
Whose answer did you find most compelling (and please explain below!)
Biden
Richardson
Kucinich
Gravel
Dodd
Hillary
Obama
Edwards

Results

Tags: , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Answers (4.00 / 1)
I voted for Hillary's, but they're all pretty good. This is sort of a slam dunk for our side.

There's a meta-question none of them addressed, understandably so. What is the future relationship of the Democratic Party and both organized and disorganized labor? I think the party and the workforce are in flux, because the Baby Boomers are still dominant. The boomer workforce is less dependent on unions (or so it thinks), and therefore the party has delivered on things like family medical leave but had a more mixed record on organized labor issues.

We'll ask President Democrat in 2009, I guess.



I am with Edwards (4.00 / 1)
John Edwards walked the walk with Labor when he became our VP candidate in '04, and has never wavered. His committment to the Movement and the Right To Organize was clear long before the current campaign. When he says that it should be as easy to join a Labor Union as it is to join the Republican Party, a part of his stump speech that he regularly tells audiences, he doesn't only say it to Labor. He speaks truth to power. I have seen how it resonates. During the weekend he and Elizabeth blitzed the State, there was a small gathering on a Sunday afternoon where I was privileged to hear him address members and representatives of the local Pipefitters and Steamfitters unions who are quite politically aware.The Representatives of the Regional Political boards of several others Unions also travelled to Hooksett from Maine and Vermont. Carpenters. Communication Workers. Postal workers. Air Traffic Controllers. Firemen....they all want to know if a candidate is serious and will stand with them when the chips are down.They know where John Edwards stands. He told it like it is. Without a healthy and growing labor Movement, America cannot be all it can be. ...from the AFL/CIO debate in Chioago. Steve Skvara worked many years for LTV Steel and was forced to retire with a disability.Two years later the company filed for Bankruptcy and he and his family lost a third of his pension, and all their health benefits.He was visibly upset and frustrated when he got to pose his question to John Edwards. Edwards answered the question with a seriousness and passion for changing this country, that we so desperately need.

Next time, there may be no next time.

[ Parent ]
I dinged both Edwards and Obama's responses (0.00 / 0)
Edwards for his banning replacement worker bill -- great concept, but a little hard to regulate and enforce -- and Obama for saying he'd walk picket lines as president. That's just a silly line.

[ Parent ]
Obama (0.00 / 0)
True, but I do think that Obama's experience as a community activist in Chicago separates him from the field in this regard.  He knows the difference that organized labor can make -- and can articulate it. 

[ Parent ]
In terms of accomplishment (4.00 / 3)
I think it's Dodd by a mile here. Frankly, he could just mention FMLA and I'd still give it to him -- what puzzles me is why the media refuses to educate the public on Dodd's authorship of that (and conversely I guess of Biden's role in the Clinton crime bill).

FMLA, FIRE, SAFER, Child Care legislation -- how can he not win this round?



I really do have to say I feel like the campaigns (4.00 / 2)
Are starting to differentiate themselves -- or maybe it's just this issue?

Honestly, if I could chinese menu this and pick one from column a, b, and c -- I'd be a happy voter. There's some good ideas in these answers.



Trade Agreements (0.00 / 0)
Clinton and Obama are both 2 out of the only twelve democrats that voted for the Oman trade agreement.  They voted for this agreement even after the slave labor and anti-sweatshop provisions were striped out.  Granted Oman does have oil and we do have four military bases there and it is in the Persian Gulf.  Oman is in the top tier of the US state dept for human trafficing and slave labor.  85% of the population does not work they share in the oil revenue and the work is performed by citizens of other countries. Tag Oman US state department. Further this was the first trade treaty to include our infrastructure, in other words they can buy our ports, water supplies, electric grid and because this is an international treaty they do not have to deal with pesky things like public opinion or congress or even the president but an international tribunal.  Oman had no labor standards or protections and did not adhere to any of the ILO labor standards. So, if you believe them I have a bridge you might be interested in.

Great Post Rick (4.00 / 1)
In return for bases we are debased.

Next time, there may be no next time.

[ Parent ]
NLRB (4.00 / 2)
I'm not on board with Biden (or any other candidate thus far), but credit him for mentioning the Bush NLRB and its hideous anti-union orientation.  The NLRB's Kentucky River decisions -- which threaten to reclassify millions of blue-collar workers as union-ineligible "supervisors" -- are a disgrace. 

Bush wants to end unions.  Period.  Case closed.  He never had to work in an unsafe mine, or had his pension stolen by rogue executives.  Bush was born with millions -- he never had to worry about having his health care taken away.

The anti-union NLRB poses a far greater threat to working families than any trade deal.  It has made it easier for corporations to fire organizers, and it has treated workers like pieces of enslaved meat.


Not sure I agree it's a bigger problem (4.00 / 1)
But I certainly agree that it is a problem. This is what happens during Republican administrations -- even the agencies that are supposed to protect ordinary Americans (like EPA) become GOP roosts.

[ Parent ]
Kucinich and Richardson (0.00 / 0)
I understand the drama of saying "withdraw from NAFTA," but didn't we get mad when Bush withdrew from the Kyoto Protocol? I wish Kucinich had said he wants to re-examine NAFTA.

Richardson's specifics serve him well here.

And prompted by Mike's enthusiasm, I re-read Dodd's. First I've heard of the Kentucky Rivers Decision -- kudos to him for opposing that.


We were never a party to Kyoto (0.00 / 0)
It was signed and not ratified. I think if Bush wanted to, he could still submit it to the Senate, but that's not likely to happen.

Not a good comparison.


[ Parent ]
You're right, my example was wrong (0.00 / 0)
Sorry about that. But my general point stands, in that we don't want the chief executive unilaterally withdrawing from multilateral agreements.

[ Parent ]
I pretty much agree (4.00 / 1)
Obviously we have the sovereign right to withdraw whenever we want, but appearing unpredictable puts our allies in a tough spot and makes everyone else wonder whether or not we're serious about our treaty commitments.

[ Parent ]
The Problem with this Election (0.00 / 0)
The last commenter said, "I voted for Hillary's but they're all pretty good."  Wrong, my friend.  Do not vote for something you don't believe in.  Joe Biden is the only candidate that actually VOTED FOR what he says HE'S FOR.  Don't tell me what they value show me their records.  It's right there before you.  You should have voted for Biden's if you support increasing the minimum wage and this country's middle class.  This is the reason Hillary is leading in the polls.  Folks, buy in to a real candidate. 

Joe Biden 2008



Connect with BH
     
Powered by: SoapBlox